|
In order
to discuss powerplants in any depth, it is essential
to understand the concepts of POWER and TORQUE.
Sometimes it seems people are confused about both entities.
People often discuss them as if they were mutually exclusive. For
example, we
have heard engine builders ask a customer:
"Do you want
your engine to make TORQUE or HORSEPOWER?"
You should be
clear on the concept that POWER is dependent on torque.
TORQUE
and RPM are the MEASURED quantities of engine output.
POWER is
CALCULATED from torque and RPM, by the following equation :
HP = Torque x RPM
÷ 5252
An engine
produces POWER by applying a TORQUE on a rotating shaft.
A dynamometer
measures torque and RPM, and from those two values calculates
observed power. Then it applies various factors (air
temperature,
barometric pressure, relative humidity) in order to correct the
observed power
to the value it would have been if it had been measured at
standard
atmospheric conditions (corrected power).
A few basic
definitions will help. First, TORQUE is defined as a
FORCE around
a given point, applied at a RADIUS from that point.
Note that the
unit of TORQUE is one pound-foot (often misstated), while
the
unit of WORK is one foot-pound.
Referring to
this picture, assume that the handle is parallel to the supported shaft
and is
located at a radius of 12" from the center of the shaft. In this
example,
consider the shaft to be fixed to the wall. Let the arrow represent a
100 lb.
force, applied in a direction perpendicular to both the handle and the
crank
arm, as shown. The shaft does not turn, but there is a
torque of
100 pounds-feet (100 pounds times 1 foot) applied to the shaft. Note
that if
the crank arm in the picture was twice as long and the handle was
located 24"
from the center of the shaft, the same 100 pound force applied to the
handle
would produce 200 lb-ft of torque (100 pounds times 2
feet).
Next,
POWER is the measure of how much WORK can be done in a
specified
TIME. In the example on the Work and Energy page, the guy
pushing the
car did 16,500 foot-pounds of WORK. If he did that work in two minutes,
he
would have produced 8250 foot-pounds per minute of POWER (165
feet x 100
pounds ÷ 2 minutes).
In the same way
that one ton is a large amount of weight (by definition,
2000
pounds), one horsepower is a large amount of power (by
definition, 33,000 foot-pounds per minute). The power the guy produced
pushing
his car across the lot (8250 foot-pounds-per-minute) equals ¼
horsepower
(8,250 ÷ 33,000).
OK, all
thats fine, but how does pushing a car across a parking lot
relate to
rotating machinery?
Consider the
handle-and-crank sketch again. The handle is 12" from the center of the
shaft,
and the shaft is now supported by frictionless bearings, and is
attached to
some rotational load behind the wall.
Suppose that a
constant force of 100 lbs. is applied to the handle so that the force
is always
perpendicular to both the handle and the crank as the crank turns. (The
"arrow"
rotates with the handle and remains in the same position relative to
the crank
and handle).
If that constant
100 lb. tangential force causes the shaft to rotate at 2000 RPM, then
the power
the shaft is transmitting to the load behind the wall is shaft is 100
lb-ft of
torque (100 lb. x 1 foot) times 2000 RPM divided by 5252, which is 38
HP.
The following
four examples illustrate the relationship.
Example
1: How much torque is required to produce 300 HP at 2700
RPM?
HP = TORQUE x RPM
÷ 5252
so
TORQUE = HP x
5252 ÷ RPM
TORQUE = 300 x
5252 ÷ 2700 = 584 lb-ft.
Example 2: How
much torque is required to produce 300 HP at 4600 RPM?
TORQUE = 300 x
5252 ÷ 4600 = 343 lb-ft.
Example 3: How
much torque is required to produce 300 HP at 8000 RPM?
TORQUE = 300 x
5252 ÷ 8000 = 197 lb-ft.
Example
4: How much torque does the turbine section of a 600 HP Garrett
TPE-331
produce? The turbine of that engine turns at 41,000 RPM, so the torque
is:
TORQUE = 600 x
5252 ÷ 41,000 = 76.86 lb-ft.
Example
5: After the 600 HP (in Example 4 above) goes through the
TPE-331
propeller gearbox, it emerges at the prop flange at 1591 RPM. How much
torque
is applied to the prop?
TORQUE = 600 x
5252 ÷ 1591= 1981 lb-ft. (ignoring losses in the
gearbox, of
course).
General Observations
In order to
design an engine to produce a particular value of HP, you must know the
RPM at
which you want that HP to occur, and design the engine to produce the
required
torque at that RPM. Typically, the torque peak will occur at a lower
RPM than
the power peak. The reason is that typically, the torque curve does not
drop
off (%) as rapidly as the RPM is increasing (%).
The RPM band
within which the engine produces its peak torque is limited. You can
tailor a
high peak with a very narrow band, or a lower peak value with a wider
band.
Those characteristics are usually dictated by the parameters of the
application
for which the engine is intended.
If an engine is
tailored to produce a peak torque of 500 lb-ft at 2500 RPM, then at
that 2500
RPM it will produce 238 HP, and the torque will be declining as speed
exceeds
2500 RPM. Suppose torque drops to 415 lb-ft at 3000 RPM. The HP is
still 238,
and the engine can do the same amount of work per unit time at 2500 as
it can
at 3000, but it will burn less fuel producing that power at 2500 RPM
than at
3000 RPM. (That's because the power consumed to turn the crankshaft and
the
reciprocating machinery attached to it increases as the square of the
crankshaft speed.)
If that same
engine is tailored to produce the same peak torque (500 lb-ft) but with
the
torque peak at 6100 RPM, the power the engine would produce at 6100 is
581 HP.
The peak HP depends on the shape of the torque curve after peak torque,
that
is, on how quickly the torque curve falls off above peak
torque.
Derivation of the
Equation
This part will
probably not be of interest to most readers, but several readers have
asked:
"OK, where does the 5252 come from?" Here is the
answer.
By definition,
POWER = FORCE x DISTANCE ÷ TIME
Using the
example above where a constant tangential force of 100 pounds was
applied to
the rotating handle at a 6" radius, we know the force, so to calculate
power,
we need the distance the handle travels per unit time.
Power = 100
pounds x distance per minute
OK, how far does
the crank handle move in one minute? First, determine the distance it
moves in
one revolution:
DISTANCE per
revolution = 2 x p
x radius
DISTANCE = 2 x
3.1416 x 1 ft = 6.283 ft. per revolution.
Now we know how far
the crank moves in one revolution. How far does the crank move in one
minute?
DISTANCE per min.
= 6.283 ft .per rev. x 60 rev. per min. = 377 feet per
minute
Now we know enough
to calculate the power, defined as:
POWER = FORCE x
DISTANCE ÷ TIME so Power = 100 lb. x 377 ft. per
minute or Power = 100 x 377 = 37,700 ft-lb per minute
Swell, but how
about HORSEPOWER?
Remember that one
HORSEPOWER is
defined as 33000 foot-pounds of work per
minute.
Therefore, HP = POWER (ft-lb per
min)
÷ 33,000
So the power
being applied to the crank-wheel above is: 37,700 ft-lb per
minute, or
1.14 HP (37,700 ÷
33,000).
Now we combine
some stuff we already know to produce the magic 5252.
We already know
that TORQUE = FORCE x RADIUS.
If we divide both
sides by RADIUS, we get:
FORCE = TORQUE
÷ RADIUS (a)
Now, if DISTANCE
per revolution = RADIUS x 2 x p
then DISTANCE per
minute = RADIUS x 2 x pi x RPM (b)
We already know
POWER = FORCE x DISTANCE per minute (c) so
if we plug the equivalent for FORCE from (a) and distance per minute from (b) into (c),
we get:
POWER = (TORQUE
÷ RADIUS) x (RPM x RADIUS x 2 x p)
Dividing both
sides by 33,000 to find HP,
HP = TORQUE
÷ RADIUS x RPM x RADIUS x 2 x p
÷ 33,000
By reducing, we
get
HP = TORQUE x RPM
x 6.28 ÷ 33,000
Since
6.2832 ÷
33000 = 1 ÷ 5252
therefore
HP = TORQUE x RPM
÷ 5252
Note that at 5252 RPM, torque
and HP are equal. At any RPM below 5252, the value of torque is greater
than
the value of HP; Above 5252 RPM, the value of torque is less than the
value of
HP.
We
thanks EPI, Inc. for those informations |